Beyond the Call of Duty: Supererogation, Obligation, and Offence
SUNY Press, 1 janv. 1991 - 226 pages
A surprisingly large number of people have denied that it is possible for human moral agents to act in such a way as to go beyond or transcend what moral duty or obligation requires of them. Some of this opposition to the possibility of supererogation, as it is called, has been motivated by theological concerns. This book surveys the concerns of Luther, Calvin, and Melanchthon, as they react to certain teachings of the Roman Catholic Church, as well as the concerns of several contemporary theologians. It also examines some contemporary philosophers whose concerns have grown out of a commitment to a Kantian, utilitarian, or prescriptive type of ethics and urges that there are valuable lessons to be learned from these theologians and philosophers. At the same time it is argued that some of their concerns are the result of a mistaken idea of what it means to perform an act of supererogation. In addition, it is argued that some of their concerns can be addressed in ways that do not require a denial of the possibility of going beyond the call of duty in human life. This stage of the argument involves a discussion of virtue ethics and an examination of the concept of vocation, particularly as it has developed in Protestant thought, and illustrates the relevance of virtue and vocation to the problem of supererogation.
Avis des internautes - Rédiger un commentaire
Aucun commentaire n'a été trouvé aux emplacements habituels.
Autres éditions - Tout afficher
according action acts of offence acts of supererogation agent anti-supererogationist appears appropriate argue argument becomes behavior believe benefits blame blameworthy bring chapter characterization Chisholm claim clear clearly commandments committed concept concerning conclude condition consequences counsels course criticism Curtis deontic described discussion erogation ethics example excuses fact fails failure favor feel follows forbidden fulfil given God's grounds hence Heyd human idea important judge judgments less lives manner moral agents moral duty moral obligation moral reasons motives negative never Nevertheless obligatory offer omission omit one's opportunities particular perfection perform acts perform an act perhaps permissible person Pharisee position possible praise praiseworthy principle Pybus qualify quasi-supererogation question realized reasons of self-interest refrain regard requirements resist seems sense simply situation soldier standard suggestion super supererogatory theory things tion true understanding violation virtue vocation