 | United States. Circuit Court (7th Circuit), Josiah Hooker Bissell - 1875 - 598 pages
...directly upon the point, is in like manner conclusive upon the same matter between the same parties coming incidentally in question in another court for a different purpose. But neither a judgment of a concurrent or exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter which came collaterally... | |
 | Simon Greenleaf - 1876 - 762 pages
...in question in another court, for a different purpose.2 But neither the judgment of a concurrent nor exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter,...nor of any matter to be inferred by argument from the judgment."3 1 20 Howell's St. Tv. 538 ; expressly in equity also. Pearce v. Gray, 2 Y. & C. adopted... | |
 | Nevada. Supreme Court - 1877 - 1090 pages
...upon the point is, in like manner, conclusive upon the same matter between the same parties coming incidentally in question in another court for a different...purpose. But neither the judgment of a concurrent nor exclusive jurisdiction. is evidence of any matter which comes collaterally in question, though... | |
 | William Wait - 1879 - 1002 pages
...upon the point is, in like manner, conclusive upon the same matter, between the same parties, coming incidentally in question in another court for a different...nor of any matter to be inferred by argument from the judgment." In support of this general doctrine, see Jfibsham v. DuUcban, 4 Watts (Penn.), 183 ;... | |
 | William J. Henry, William Logan Harris - 1879 - 534 pages
...directly upon the point, is in like manner conclusive upon the same matter between the same parties coming incidentally in question in another court for a different...purpose ; but neither the judgment of a concurrent nor an exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter which came collaterally in question, though... | |
 | 1920 - 1058 pages
...Duchess of Kingston's Case the court, after stating when a former judgment will sustain the plea, said: "But neither the judgment of a concurrent or exclusive...nor of any matter to be Inferred by argument from the judgment." In Hopkins v. Lee it was held : "To points which came only collaterally under consideration,... | |
 | David Sutherland (barrister-at-law.), Great Britain. Privy Council. Judicial Committee - 1880 - 1060 pages
...upon the point, is in like manner conclusive upon the same matter, between the same parties, coming incidentally in question in another Court for a different...exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter which comes collaterally in question, though within their jurisdiction, nor of any matter incidentally cognizable,... | |
 | Austin Abbott - 1880 - 928 pages
...between the same parties, coming incidentally in question in another court for another purpose; 3. But neither the judgment of a concurrent or exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter incidentally cognizable, nor of any matter to be inferred by argument from the judgment.1 1 Duchess... | |
 | 1881 - 740 pages
...jurisdiction, directly upon the point, is conclusive upon the same matter between the same parties coming incidentally in question in another Court for a different...a concurrent or exclusive jurisdiction is evidence " (that is, as I understand the meaning of the Chief Justice, conclusive evidence) " of any matter... | |
 | Great Britain. Magistrates' cases - 1882 - 688 pages
..."jurisdiction, directly upon the point, is conclusive upon the same matter between the same parties coming incidentally in question in another court for a different...concurrent or exclusive jurisdiction is evidence" (that is, as I understand the meaning of the Chief Justice, conclusive evidence) " of any matter which... | |
| |
But neither the judgment of a concurrent or exclusive jurisdiction is evidence of any matter which came collaterally in question, though within their jurisdiction, nor of any matter incidentally cognizable, nor of any matter to be inferred by argument... 
